Think it may be the theme.
Deactivating Plugins chipped away a little bit but the theme brought the load time down the most. Still not blazing fast but could probably live with it.
So if it is the theme, what might I do to troubleshoot that, aside from choosing a different one. The theme I’ve chose has tons of widgets and images, so it’s going to take longer to load regardless, but I’m not sure why it would cause a holdup initially.