I could not reverse it. After removing the conditions, changing the conditions and even adding conditions to allow all nothing changed. Removed the plugin and deleted the folder and still nothing. I had to do a full file restore and still no go, I did a full database backup after that and my site was then ok.
Yes, I do use caching but I made sure to purge the cache from the server, lightspeed addon which is connected to the server, Cloudflare was purged and my web browser. Did the purges several times and waited a good amount of time.
The Content Control plugin worked well but removing it was an issue because the rules always stayed in effect even without the plugin and files present, my guess is that it was something with the database.