I removed the disable one and figured out the problem is not happening when I manually add users. However, when people buy products on my website they receive a different mail. This is [email protected]
I use Easy Digital Downloads. Do you happen to know if that conflicts with your plugin?
Awesome, thanks! I indeed used the wrong shortcode, did not realize it was a different one in a different message. You are not to blame, the information on the website is correct, I simply did not read it correctly.