That fixed it! Sadly I spent hours turning off and on various features. I’m using the Better WP Security plugin which has a ton of options to tweak, I was sure that was it. So I deactivated the security plugin and then my whole site went down. Apparently you can’t just deactivate it without turning off all the options first. But that’s not a discussion for here lol. I wrote my review after going through every plugin but I completely overlooked Jetpack! If I could change my rating, I would. Everything works as described now. You’re a great plugin author. Thank you.