Hi Scott,
Sorry, it took me some times to get back to you.
First I tried to activate debug mode and with my theme It just did not work.
I may need to contact my theme again to fix this issue. I use Jupiter.
(will take some time )
I need to mention that I tried other plugins and I could not find anything like yours.
When I reactivate your plugin, all my contact forms are gone. I need to create them again to test your plugin.
I somehow doubt I can fix this problem without giving you access to my admin. Let me know what is the secure way to do it. Can I contact you directly?
Please let me know if you can help me, I want to buy pro version, if this plugin works with my theme.
Thank you for your support.