Here’s another warning I found, it doesn’t deserve a full topic so I’m adding it here, too bad I can’t change the title. Here’s another PHP warning when showing comments:
PHP Warning: Attempt to read property "display_name" on bool in /data/wp-content/themes/graphene/inc/comments.php on line 232
When the plugins tries to fetch the author of a comment, it uses get_userdata to get the WP_User object. If the author doesn’t exist anymore, the function returns false, so it tries to get the display_name of a boolean, hence the warning.