I am so late to this party but maybe it’ll help some other poor souls trying to wrap their heads around this theme.
There are two ways of fixing this! The file adventurechick is speaking of is Theme Functions.php! Look for /* Jetpack Infinite Scroll */ and you’ll find ‘posts_per_page’. You can change how many circles show up through that.
If you change that and there’s still not the right amount of circles, then it’s a wordpress thing! Go to Settings > Reading Settings and you’ll find “Blog pages show at most” in there. Change it to the same number as what you put in the php script.
Hope that helps!
