I figured out what happened. Not why, but what! After I updated the plugin, my WordPress thought I uninstalled Caldera Forms (and I didn’t notice it really since the Anti-Spam was still there). I tried to reinstall, but the folder was still there, so I had to go into my site via FTP to manually delete the Caldera Forms folder and reinstall. A bit frustrating since now I have to set up my forms again, but at least it was resolved! Thanks for the quick response. ??
