Thanks for your quick reply, Cornel. I did exactly as you said and pasted the URL you shared (replacing “mysite” with my actual site) and changed the date range, clicked filter, selected all, and then clicked export. I got the same results as before, just the two columns.
What gives?
This reply was modified 1 year, 7 months ago by kitchenstew.
Our host was able to help with this since the plugin developer didn’t respond. I’ll take a sec to respond here in case it can help anyone in the future.
We were using PHP mailer which is apparently not a good protocol in terms of sending email. Installing a plugin ‘WP SMTP’ will force SMTP on outgoing emails. SMTP is a better protocol in terms of email deliverability.