It works now because I completely deleted the WP Ultimate recipe plugin so now I know that was the issue. Which is very unfortunate as I put a lot of work into posts under that plugin. I re did categories without the plugin and started over. So now I need to figure out a good reciep plugin to add that will not mess up the categories like the WP Ultimate recipe plugin did. If anyone has any suggestions on good, simple recipe plug ins that show up well on search engines, that would be great! Decided not to use the WP Ultimate one anymore.