Thanks for your response Michael.
I’m trying to troubleshoot this issue still and I’m trying to narrow down the possibilities. Do you know if it would have anything to do with my hosting? Or would it have anything to do with how I have my archive templates set up?
The other thing I notices is when I save the Etsy Importer settings, it goes to a blank browser screen instead of staying in the admin. Could it be that I need to reinstall the plugin?