CSS issue…
#navbarleft: 680px;
Your menu options are running wider than 680px and create a new row. If you look closely in MSIE you can see the descender from the “g” in weddings peeking out from underneath the “good” of “about good shepherd”.
You’ve got too many menu options. Seven is enough major options anyways. Rethink your site layout to make better use of the topnav->subnav.