infrastratos

Yep, I changed the outgoing email address in the WP User Control widget and that solved the issue.

Nevermind, it turned out to indeed be a plugin conflict, one I didn’t suspect – WP User Control. You can add to your notes that if there’s a different email address specified in the WP User Control widget it will create a conflict.

thanks,
– Kristin

Thanks, I tried this but unfortunately it didn’t work either, the new account is only referenced as reply-to and the aol email remains the sender.

Yes I’ve tested deactivating other plugins and the same thing continues to happen, do you have any other recs?