Godigitalplus

Hello Larry, The problem is you are using a share button not the like box, SO it is showing how many times that post has been shared or liked.

To show the like count of your page use https://developers.facebook.com/docs/reference/plugins/like-box/

No not a issue with Theme. I tried switching it. The worst part is its happening with all wordpress installations, All new and existing installations.

Problem solved.. The faulty plugin was Block-Spam-By-Math-Reloaded. Thanks Esmi!