Sorry for the confusion! I’ve found that the plugin protects contents of pages unless they contain blog posts. So, if the page is a member’s only section, for instance, that includes a special blog, those posts will always be visible regardless of whether or not I’ve asked it the plugin to protect the content.
However, if the page I’m protecting is a contact area that does not contain posts (for example), the plugin will in fact protect the content.
Whenever I am trying to protect a page containing blog posts the plugin seems ineffective.
Let me know if that clears things up! Thanks!