@jkilgore55 – I have been having the same problem for days but have managed to solve it on my site by installing the “WP Mail SMTP” plugin.
With it, I used the unrestricted Gmail SMTP server with the following settings:
– Send all WordPress emails via SMTP.
SMTP Host: aspmx.l.google.com
SMTP Port: 25
– No encryption.
– No: Do not use SMTP authentication.
(No need for username or password).
I hope this works for you, I know how frustrating this can be!