Just wanted to pass along an update. After a lot of digging, I found the problem and have things back on track.
Long story short: I had done some work on the theme and the default page of the theme was basically telling the site: “if you see ‘login’, show page-login no matter what.
So I’ve dug that part out it looks like I’m good to go.
I’m actually glad this was my bad, because the plugin rocks. Thanks for all the hard work, Jeff!
Oh, and I see your site is back online. Good deal!
