I also forgot to say I have the Nav Menu Roles plugin installed so that I can show a custom menu for the users who are logged in.
And I meant BAW login/logout plugin, not BAQ, lol. It was working well until I added the BAW plugin, does that mean I just need to find something else? I used sidebar login plugin in before that but it had other issues that BAW solved, but then caused new ones. Maybe a new login/logout plugin suggestion?