Thanks for the reply and sorry for the delay.
So, I went into cpanel and created a wildcard subdomain for *.domainname.com … and nothing changed, it still doesn’t work. I go to whatsmydns.net and they do not have the same IP – the subdomains propagate only in Pasadena and nowhere else, with a different address than the main domain – even though I set up wildcard subdomains. Help!