blalow

OK I figured it out!

When speeds are the issue, you may need to check out your .htaccess file. Mine was over 180000 lines long for some sort of old IP address security that we no longer use!

It is faster with twentyfifteen, but it is still really slow: 5 seconds!

Here are the logs so you can see how slow it is:

https://cabosanlucasfishingcharter.us/apache-logs-showing-slow-response-time