Someone helped me with this work-around. I did not use the plugin and instead added the standard Wibiya code inside this little conditional tag in footer.php:
<?php if(!is_ssl())
{
/* Preventing toolbar from being printed on ssl pages */
echo’
<script src=”https://cdn.wibiya.com/Toolbars/dir_xx/Toolbar_xx/Loader_xx.js” type=”text/javascript”> </script><noscript>Web Toolbar by Wibiya</noscript>’;
}
?>
WordPress has help pages on their conditional tags if one wants to omit other pages from showing the toolbar. Though, since this is not a plugin, the above will have to be re-entered into footer.php if one updates WP.