Hi Rhys: I am also having trouble with this situation. I see a note that that “There are 25 e-mail addresses that have been unconfirmed”. I have submitted a few addresses of my own to ensure the system was working properly before requesting people sign up. I checked my spam folder and did not receive anything from the program. I am using the most up-to-date WordPress release on a professionally maintained server.
If there is no known solution can you instead tell me how to extract the contact information? I would like to confirm it manually so as not to annoy people signing up. My email address is [email protected] while my site is at https://www.bigjohnbates.ca. I currently have no email addresses running at bigjohnbates.ca as I didn’t note this was a requirement. Thanks – John