Thanks for the reply.
Godaddy is not blocking the email. There is no trigger or attempt to send email that I can see when someone subscribes or a new post is posted that matches a subscriber.
When I resend the email conformation for a new subscriber it sends the email.
When I change a post to “Draft” and then re-publish, the mail gets sent immediately.
Seems to be an issue with the initial email trigger maybe?
I’ve rechecked all compose and post notifications and they are correct.
I misspoke about the admin mail, it also only gets sent on resend.
I am using Group Selector to show categories on form.
Also I have the same issue on both my staging site and production.
I have also tried disabling all plugins with no success.
I really like the product and would love to find a way to make it work.
Please let me know if you need any more information that might help resolve the issue.