Wrong tab highlighted in navbar

Web address is https://www.theprefref.com, but it is login only.

Hopefully a simple fix…

I have two extra pages added named “About Us” and “Contact” that each have tabs in the navbar. However, whenever they are clicked, the correct page comes up but the “Home” tab is the one that is highlighted. The content all looks correct on the page, the only problem is in the navbar.

I also noticed that I gave these pages both custom slugs, but the slugs show up as “?pageid=2” or something similar. The other pages on the site that don’t have link tabs in the navbar have slugs created the same way, but their slugs still show up properly when they are visited, so I’m assuming it’s a problem the navbar is creating.

It’s not a major issue, but I have no idea what could be causing this so I don’t know where to start. Any opinions would be greatly appreciated!!!