• Hey, this morning I was notified that I have a new pingback on one of my posts. I looked into it and it was this Russian tutorials site which copied and pasted my whole post, and linking to the original in the end of the post.
    Original


    The Russian post

    Should I accept this pingback? the guy also commented on the post with the link to the post. Should I allow this? Is this considered stealing or just offering a translation?

    I’d like to hear some advice…
    Thank you

Viewing 3 replies - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • It’s really entirely up to you how you want to proceed.

    I personally don’t accept any pingbacks. You may find them helpful, or not.

    which copied and pasted my whole post

    Actually, they translated it… and that’s quite a bit of work compared to copy/paste. (I know, I used to work as a translator for years!)
    Nevertheless, I find the way it was done – not OK. Yes, your post is mentioned at the bottom (“the English original is here“) in a link but neither your name/blog title, nor the images’ copyright is mentioned.

    So, while I wouldn’t consider a translation a “copy” or “stealing” (see your tags) – your transformed images could be considered stolen (although I suspect you don’t own the publishing right for the AJ photo… so that’s a very blurred situation there, one might ask: where did you steal that photo from?).

    Now, regardless of this very muddy photo question – the copyright of your published text is still yours, the copyright of the Russian text is his. If this was a book and translated into another language, it would work like this:
    – the publisher of the translation pays royalties to:
    a) the owner of the original copyright (a small % fee according to international agreements)
    b) the translator (the sum agreed in their contract)
    Both copyright notices (original and translation) should be printed in the impressum of the book.

    Actually, I find pingbacks and trackbacks useful.

    Thread Starter yoni08

    (@yoni08)

    thanks moshu,
    I contacted the guy, I don’t think it affected his decision though

Viewing 3 replies - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • The topic ‘What should I do?’ is closed to new replies.