Hello, @bcs213
Thanks for your patience here.
I see initially you mentioned a reinstallation did not work. Can you confirm if you’ve only tried a reinstall on one site? It sounds like you did completely wipe the tables in that case, however, I want to confirm and go over a few of the initial steps again.
Please try the following. First, on one of the sites having the issue, try deactivating the plugin and using the top option to “Keep all Wordfence tables and data” and then complete the deactivation. From there, reactivate the plugin and let me know if the issue persists.
If it does, try deactivating and clearing the tables again, using the bottom option in the prompt “Delete all Wordfence tables and data“. After that, let me know if the issue still persists. With WPEngine, that should fix the issue. If the issue does continue, please send over the diagnostics from that same site to [email protected] (via Wordfence > Tools > Diagnostics > Send Report by Mail) with your forum username in the 2nd field there. Let me know here when those are sent and I’ll check that over with the QA team at that point.
Thanks,
Scott