Using S2Member with Woocommerce and alternative view menu but redirect not hide

I am using S2Member ( version 140423) with Woocommerce(version 2.1.7) and I have set restrictions so that the user has to logon to be able to use the shop. I have also created a menu which includes the Shop tab. I have added restriction to the Shop page and added a member options page but the Shop tab is still showing and not redirecting to a login page. The only way I have been able to fix this is by Going to Alternative views and checking ALL which then hides the shop tab if you are not loged in. What i want to do is if the user is not logged in for them to see the shop tab but be redirected to login – i think this worked until i craeted a new menu. Any help appreciated.