User Search

So, I have this issue with wordpress right now. I’m running a subscription site that has roughly 1300 subscribers. Sometimes things need to be addressed with subscriber’s profiles and so-on.

Here’s my problem, when I search for users by user-meta (like their first name) for example, “melissa”, all that is shown is 2 results. ((btw, I’ve inserted some code that will search user-meta, not just the normal wp user search)). However, my total number of items found in the search result is 45. There are no pagination arrows that show up either.

What could be happening that would only show 2 results, when really it’s telling me that there is 45 actual results?