• I realize this is the ‘beta’ version for testing and feedback, but it looks more like an ‘alpha-2’ release. I also accept that any major change requires a learning curve. That said, after minor testing on a new install with the Twenty Seventeen theme, I’m completely underwhelmed. My first observations are:

    1. Too many clicks to do anything. If you’re trying to compete with drag-and-drop, you missed the point.
    2. I can’t figure out how to resize an embedded video from a URL. They are all 350 x 150.
    3. I can’t embed a video from a Facebook URL in a video block, but I can as a theme widget.
    4. The ‘Columns’ block notes it’s in beta, but until basic responsive functionality works, this is not a beta release.

    I’m all for making improvements for the personal bloggers on wordpress.com to compete with Wix, Weebly, Squarespace, or whatever drag-and-drop pagebuilder you seem to want to address; however, that is a completely different user base than those of us who use WordPress as a development platform for more complex sites.

    It appears from the other comments that the dev platform user base is quite happy with Visual Composer/WP Bakery, Divi, Beaver Builder, and other editing solutions we pay for as plugins or are included in premium themes. Disrupting this part of the industry to placate the blogger/cat picture posters is absurd.

    As an old Drupal developer turned WordPress convert for the simplicity of development, integrations, as well as user documentation and training, I will have to rethink my recommendations to my clients. For now, I’ve turned off all automatic updates and will be watching for future updates and reviewing alternative CMS platforms.

Viewing 1 replies (of 1 total)
  • Plugin Author Tammie Lister

    (@karmatosed)

    First, thanks for the review @rdillard.

    I would love to learn a little more about this:

    > can’t embed a video from a Facebook URL in a video block, but I can as a theme widget.

    This feels like it could be a bug to me. Would you be able to open up an issue here: https://github.com/WordPress/gutenberg/issues/new? If not, I can for you if you can provide me a little more information.

    It’s worth adding columns does have responsive features planned, do you have any ideas yourself of what that could be? Would be great to explore what for you that would need to have.

Viewing 1 replies (of 1 total)
  • The topic ‘Underwhelmed’ is closed to new replies.