Good to hear from you! Sorry to hear about your previous site.
I’ve made updates to the Photog theme all throughout the spring 2012. As you mentioned, a lot has changed in WordPress and its documentation since Photog was last updated in 2009.
I’d still say it’s a pretty good theme as it makes most of the first-time visitors say “wow, that’s a serious site you’ve made” on the first look, but would require a maintenance overhaul in order to reduce the bounce rate of visitors and to allow for certain WP 3 niceties.
The main thing would be to make the theme have less of a graphical imprint on the screen so content can really be the king. Biggest culprit is the file https://wp-themes.com/wp-content/themes/photog/images/header.jpg, of which I’d have taken off the light, the lens and the two curvy panels next to it, other one of which has the WordPress logo.
Image editing isn’t my thing and a technically more advanced theme has its benefits, so at the moment I’m looking forward to converting my Photog site to use Elbee Elgee.
There’s lots of good about Photog, so I hope it doesn’t get deleted from the repository. It’s possible to use the version of the theme I have in use now with its 100+ updates (though a few should be reverted as they’re site-specific) or, even better, redo it as an Elbee Elgee child-theme.
I’m not up for the latter task by myself, though, as what I’m looking for when converting my Photog site is to say goodbye to most of the graphical elements in Photog to conserve the valuable screen real estate. If you’d be willing to make a compressed version of the header.jpg, I might be willing to give it a shot, though. Would be good to do the changes gradually in order to not to shock the users.
My schedule for the theme switch would be late Autumn in the earliest, as I’m concentrating on another site in the immediate future.
Glad to hear about your new theme. All of its versions seem like they’d be delightful for some site admins. In themes, it’s best for all of the web when there are many options for site admins to choose from to keep the websites from looking as clones of each other. If I’d make a theme I wouldn’t mind it not getting popular, unless it was a framework theme on which child-themes would be developed. That might be a direction you’d want to go, too: either to make a framework on which you’d also offer different child-themes to cater for site admins with different tastes or needs, or to adopt an already-made framework like Elbee Elgee and to only make child-themes.