text page = text mail ?

No one ? ??

Hi @vbdeco,

On the version that you are working that is “normal”. As a matter of fact, both messages should be different. The reason why the plugin acts like that is because in a former version the manage link was visible to anyone using the plugin so this was a security issue, this is why I remove the link.

In a future version I will have both sections to controll the messages.

I have a newer version but right now is not release into WordPress, would you like to try the development version?

Regards.!!

Hi @reedyseth,

would you like to try the development version?

Why not ? But i’m not sure i know how to intall it manually.

Regards.

Hi @reedyseth,

I believe I’m also having the same issue, so I would also like to give the development version a try.

For me, when someone requests their management page, after submitting their email address, they see the “Management message” found under the Notifications tab, which is supposed to be the content of the email they receive.

What they should see on-page is the content of the “Request submitted” field under the Management tab.

I read your answer above but it doesn’t make sense to me because, if the “Request submitted” text was displayed, this wouldn’t be a security issue since no link to the management page would be displayed. As is, there is a link to the management page displayed, but at least it isn’t personalized…

@julie,

Yes that behavior is not quite well. Although I haven’t work through this issue a lot I have made some changes on it.

You can get the development version here:

https://github.com/stcr/subscribe-to-comments-reloaded/archive/development.zip

You can follow this walkthrough:

https://github.com/stcr/subscribe-to-comments-reloaded/wiki/KB#Install-New-Release

Just instead of using the pre-release you will be using the development one.

If you still have issue or question installling it let me know.

NOTE: Do not delete the plugin using the WordPress option because you will wipe out your subscribers.

@reedyseth,

There are many problems with this new version

1- For subscribe without comment : When the email address is entered and validated, then the page that appears contains the email subscription management (one under the tab notification).
2- The received mail contains a non-clickable link. If you copy / paste this link, you arrive on a page with the following message: “Woohaa the link to manage your subscriptions has expired, don’t worry, just enter your email below and a new link will be send.”
3- Same problem that describe before when people ask to manage their inscriptions on website.

I sent you my website link yesterday, so you could test if you want. I will replace this pluggin version by the old one in few day (just let me know when your tests will be finish).

Regards

@vbdeco,

Thank you for the feedback, I will check’em up.

Great Job on testing.

Hi again,

Regarding the new issues that @vbdeco mentioned:

1) I can reproduce this error. When someone clicks the “Subscribe without commenting” link, they are brought to the correct page (content from the “Request Link” field in the Management Page tab). Once the email address has been submitted, the content from the Management Message field of the Notifications tab is displayed. In the current repository version of the plugin, version 160115, the correct message was displayed (content of the Request Submitted field on the Management Page tab).

2) I can only reproduce this error when a user subscribes while commenting. NB: There should be a field to edit this message on the Management Page tab…

However, note that for me, when a user subscribes without commenting, they receive the wrong email message entirely. The “Double check message” from the Notifications tab is not sent. Instead, the “Management message” (same tab) is sent. And as described in this Github thread, both the manager_link and oneclick_link tags generate the Request Link field content from the Management tab instead of the personalized management page or the content of the One-click Unsubscribe field from the Notifications tab, respectively. This means that users are sent on a perpetual loop, and can never confirm their subscription.

I believe this is due to the fact that when a user subscribes without commenting, they are no longer added to the Manage subscribers tab. The plugin can’t send out a confirmation / Double-check message if there’s no new subscription to confirm in the first place…

3) Ditto ?? However, conversely to #2 above, the manger_link tag does work, though the oneclick_link tag doesn’t — both display the personalized management page.

Since the current repository version works much better, I will revert to that version, but I’ll try to see if I can help troubleshoot a little more… Note that all my testing has been done in logged-out state.

Hi,

Is this resolved with new version (v160831) ?

Regards

Hi,

I tested your lastest version :
1- not fix.
2- Worth : E-mail received is empty.
3-
a- When the email address is entered and validated, then the page that appears contains the email subscription management.
b- Worth : E-mail received is empty.

Regards

3a- Fixed
3b- Fixed

I need to resume (sorry) :

I don’t speak very well English, so i copy/paste and modify Julie’s Message (my appologies for this)

This new version doesn’t fix that :
So when someone clicks the “Subscribe without commenting” link, they are brought to the correct page (content from the “Request Link” field in the Management Page tab). Once the email address has been submitted, the content from the Management Message field of the Notifications tab is displayed. In the version 160115 of the plugin, the correct message was displayed (content of the Request Submitted field on the Management Page tab).

The user which subscribes without commenting, receive the wrong email message entirely. The “check message” from the Notifications tab is not sent. Instead, the “Management message” (same tab) is sent.

Hope it will help you to resolve.

Hi,

While I continue checking this issue, could please follow this steps?

https://github.com/stcr/subscribe-to-comments-reloaded/issues/250#issuecomment-243936592

it is related with blank emails and correct email message.

Hi,

I followed that link, but it does not fix my problem.

Regards.

Hi,

Resolved with new version !

Thank you. Great job !