Tax is showing up on BOTH products

Hi there,
Using this plugin with both digital and physical products… but tax is taxing BOTH products even though I only want it for one. But even if I forgo the tax and check off no tax for both bundle products, it still shows up as double tax.

I’ve unchecked tax within the Bundled product AND within BOTH products individually themselves…

Any ideas how to fix this and what to do about it?
Thanks!!