Simple, elegant, WYSIWYG

Check the screenshot. You have all those options.

I tried many plugins for social icons – either they were cheating (the social media site was opened after a redirect from their site) or even the basic customizations were in paid version.

In addition, the author is super responsive (no pun intended :)).
I would very easily recommend it to all.

This might not be the right plugin for you if you want to show the number of followers/ likes/ shares etc but the best plugin if you want to direct people to your page/ profile on social media.