Sending to admin, but not users

I have the same problem, the test e-mail is going out fine but when I test it on a user it goes back to the old plain e-mail.
I’m on twentyeleven and have these plugins:

– gravity forms
– members
– profile builder pro
– yoast seo
– WP Mail From II (not the culprit, it behaves the same without it)

Any hint?

I think the conflict lies in Profile Builder as somebody else also mentioned on your blog but I really don’t know how to solve it.

I’m having the same issue, I have Profile builder pro as well. WordPress 3.5. Any fix would be appreciated.

My fix was to switch to WYSIJA… it works great for me and it’s free if you have a list with less than 1000 subscribers.

teolives,

Does that plugin allow modification of site registration emails, password reset notifications, etc? I didnt see anything on the feature list.

Thx

Nope, but I’d achieved that already with Profile Builder plus a custom plugin (I’ve found the instructions on their site though: https://www.cozmoslabs.com/wordpress-profile-builder/documentation/)

Exactly what i was looking for!

Thanks!