Select all Attributes Except One in Product Variation

I have a product with 9 different variations and I need to be able to set the same price for all except one.

At first, I tried creating a broad variation where the attributes were set to “Any” and I defined the price, then I created a second variation specific to my one item that will have a higher price.

Unfortunately, the second variation’s price is still being overridden by the first one.

Is there no way in WooCommerce to say “all but one” attribute? I understand I could instead make 9 unique variations, set 8 of their prices the same and set the 9th variation price different, but that seems like a lot of additional work to do something simple. This problem would also compound as I add more variations in the future.