Hello @shanon-walter,
I fully examined the issue you have raised on this topic and could not see it on my end.
Are these two sites different? and do you use the child theme?
Please share a live URL from the issue.
Also, if you have any custom CSS for this; For troubleshooting, please do the following steps and let me know the results:
1- Remove all customization CSS(usually in customizer > custom code > css).
2- add your customization one by one.
3- After adding each customization code, check your issue.
Note 1: in the staging website, if you have a cache plugin or server cache. You need to clear its cache contents or disable them.
Note 2: Please get a full backup from your website before it.
Best Regards