Saved settings reset when I use a quick option that mirrors the saved settings

When I change my settings to test the different I save the settings. I then use the quick option that mirrors the settings I’ve saved. Once the quick option refreshes the page, my settings get reset – my ‘Async Javascript Method’ changes to Async, my ‘jQuery’ setting changes to Defer, and my ‘Autoptimize Javascript Method’ changes to Async. I can’t be sure if my settings get applied at all, and I can’t tell what the settings are that are applied.

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]