Hi @noellesteegs, after logging in, the user will be redirected to the last page he/she visits, or the Admin page if that user went directly to the login page. Can you please test by deactivating all plugins except RSA, then switch back to the default theme to see if RSA causes the issue?
I have deactivated all plugins except Restricted Site Access, amr shortcode any widget and bbPress – the latter two are required for the login form. I have also switched to Twentytwenty.
No, I mean that after logging in with correct credentials, the user gets redirected to the login page again with a badge showing the user is logged in.