I don’t understand what you said:
” I need something that looks more like a Page and separates itself from the posts. “
‘looks more like a Page’
Pages are html/css just like any other post. Granted, depending on your theme they may be much different base templates. But you can style stuff all you want, with minor tricks (an extra DIV wrapping the posts you care about gives you all the power in the world…).
‘separates itself from the posts’
CG-PostOrder does that, effectively, by putting tagged posts ‘at the top of the list’. Like a forum sticky, yes.
CG-PostOrder also inserts its own variable into the $post structure, so you can test (and do optional stuff) for Ordered posts. for instance:
// inside start of post loop
if (isset($post->postorder)) echo '<div class="sticky">';
...
... do normal post-loop output ...
...
if (isset($post->postorder)) echo '</div>';
Then, you can do custom CSS using:
.sticky {..}
-d