Pop Up Not showing for all users

The pop up we created using this plugin is only showing for users who are logged into the backend of the site and not for all users. We need the popup to display for all users visiting the site. I have selected the “All users” option for the Decide Where Popup Will Be Displayed and still no luck. I also have all pages selected with no luck.

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]