[Plugin: W3 Total Cache] WordPress Failure Notice and Incorrect Content

We are trying to get W3 Total Cache up and running and are having trouble with logging in and out as well as showing the correct content based on whether you’re logged in or out.

When we log out we get a WordPress Failure Notice where it says “You are attempting to log out of …. Do you really want to log out?” When we click log out sometimes we are able to log out and other times not.

Here is what I’ve tried:
– I made sure that we weren’t caching content for logged in users.
– I turned all the different types of caching on, then turned them off one by one to see if any of them would fix the problem. When I turned off database, object, and page caching at once it seemed to fix the problem, but of course I want those to be turned on.

Any suggestions?