Version 4.4 now generates it’s own page “on-the-fly”, not using a static WP page. In the early release I had forgotten to take into consideration that everybody would already have a static “Login” page from the previous versions. However, within a day I committed a fix for that problem that respects a custom “Login” page if it exists (must be titled “Login”) or creates one on the fly if it doesn’t. So, if you haven’t yet, delete the plugin and re-download/re-install it.
If you need the login page to show up in your page list, create a page titled “Login” and use the following shortcode:
[theme-my-login show_title="0" before_widget="" after_widget="" instance="tml-page"]
If you don’t want it in your pagelist, simply delete the page “Login” and it will be dynamically generated each time it is called.
As far as all the comments showing up on the login page, I am looking for a viable fix for this. This happens because the dynamic page doesn’t have an ID, so your template is pulling up ALL comments for ALL ID’s.
To ride559: I don’t even understand all that your saying. Just know that the plugin is available for FREE and it will not bother me ONE BIT if you stop using it, since it is so hideous.
Also, a usage guide can be found here (still in progress).