Pagination on Categories

Hi,

I was wonder is it possible to fix pagination for categories!?

For example, under this category https://www.footballtalk.org/players/ I have 15 posts. In the reading settings, I set up to show 12 posts per page, so the other 3 posts should be on the second page. But, when I click on page 2 I got nothing https://www.footballtalk.org/players/page/2/ (404 Not Found).

Is there any way to fix it?

Thanks