Other payment methods not showing

Hi, I’m building a shop in my dev environment using Woocommerce and using this plugin to handle paypal payments. However, when I proceed to checkout after I’ve already made a purchase, other payment options are no longer displayed.

Here are the steps to recreate:
1. Add product to cart and proceed to checkout
3. On the cart I have stripe and paypal payment options (stripe using WooCommerce Stripe Gateway and your plugin for Paypal)
2. Pay via paypal
3. Go through payment process and to thank you page (so far so good)
5. Go back to the shop and add the same product to the cart and proceed to checkout again

–> Here is my problem:
Checkout page no longer displays other payment payment options. It just has a ‘Cancel order’ button or Pay Now (which i think is taking me to Paypal again.
Stripe options are no longer there.

If I click Pay Now I get this error: UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY error – Order already captured.If ‘intent=CAPTURE’ only one capture per order is allowed.

Any thoughts?

It might be worth noting that if I uninstall this plugin and simply use the Woocommerce Stripe payment gateway, I cannot recreate this. I can reorder as many times as I like with no problems.