Only Featured posts showing up on homepage

I’m running the eDegree theme with the Featured Content Gallery Plugin on this site. https://www.idahocycling.com/. It seems that only posts that are marked as “Featured” (so they show up in the image slider) are appearing on the homepage. I took the site over from a previous webmaster and he has the Front Page Category plugin installed but even if I check all the category boxes or deactivate the plugin I still only get “Featured” posts on the front page. Any ideas on how to get just a generic post to show up on the homepage? Or am I missing something?