Hi @ckluver66, I just ran a couple of tests and recorded the results as a couple of videos. You can download the zip file containing both videos here.
As you can see, the “switch theme” links work great when the user is logged out. The first video shows the “everyone” option, and the second video shows the “passkey” option. This is how the plugin works normally. So if what you see in the videos is not what is happening on your site, something (like another plugin or theme) is interfering with normal functionality. In which case, I would be glad to help troubleshoot if you post in the actual plugin Support Forum.