• Resolved wpkiller

    (@wpkiller)


    Hi and thank you for the great plugin.
    I was playing with it for the last couple of hours, and realized there’s a feature I’m missing.
    Actually, I want to build a site where there would be a few reviewers which for sure will also review the same book, and I’d like these reviews to be grouped/indexed under the same book’s meta.

    Do you think it’d be possible to add?
    Thanks in advance!

Viewing 5 replies - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Plugin Author Kemory Grubb

    (@w33zy)

    Hello,
    Can you help be understand your request better,
    Are you referring to a situation where a book is a separate entity from a review? Then 1 book could have many reviewers and 1 reviewer could have many books?

    Thread Starter wpkiller

    (@wpkiller)

    Exactly!
    I want to have a few reviewers which can review the same book.

    Thank you for your prompt reply. Appreciated!

    Plugin Author Kemory Grubb

    (@w33zy)

    Hello again,
    the use case you have in mind, the one I outlined currently is not possible with the plugin as it is right now. For me to implement such this feature would require a complete rewrite of the plugin.

    The thing is, that use case with books and reviews being separate entities was the original plan for the plugin. However when I started to implement it I found out the WP database doesn’t have an interface to easily build “one-to-many” relationships with custom post types. For me to implement this myself would involve writing my own database methods and queries, along with my own database table inside WordPress. So I decided this would be too much of a challenge for my first official plugin, which may lead to technical depth down the line.

    With that said, I was thinking how I would approach this if I were you, using the plugin as it is. What I would do is, firstly, change the plugin slug to book. Your website would then refer to the custom post types as “books”. Then create a new book, fill out all the required information for the book such as the title, publisher, series, etc. Save the book without any actual review content. Then create a regular WP post and use the “Add Review” button to add the book and its information to the post via the [rcno-reviews] shortcode. When you publish the post you’ll have the book’s information embedded in the post. This way many user posts could be attached to one book.

    How would this solution work for you?

    Thread Starter wpkiller

    (@wpkiller)

    Interesting. That’s something I thought of as well.
    My only issue with it is the hierarchy.

    My problem with your idea is that I won’t have the possibility to show a page with all reviews for the same book, unless done manually.

    I wanted to have something like this:
    – In the homepage to show all genres.
    – Clicking a genre will show all books in it.
    – Clicking a book will show all reviews for it.

    I thought of making each genre a category and each book in the genre a sub-category.
    Then I should be able to show the the genres as categories in the homepage, the sub categories after clicking each category and then the review.

    Well, I guess without trying it live, I won’t know. ??

    Thanks a lot for your good will and help. If you have any other idea, I’d be happy to hear.

    Plugin Author Kemory Grubb

    (@w33zy)

    Run with idea you have as it seems doable to me, then provide me with a link to the site if you want any suggestions from me or a feature I could tweak to improve your use case.

Viewing 5 replies - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • The topic ‘New feature request – multiple reviews’ is closed to new replies.