Login Alert Malfunction

In the All Options section there is an option for alerting when an admin logs in. There are two options:

• Alert me when someone with administrator access signs in
• Only alert me when that administrator signs in from a new device or location

When selecting both options it still sends emails when I login from my same computer each day. This used to work as intended and would only send me an email when I logged in from a new computer.

Proper behavior: only send alert email when logging in from a new computer
What is it doing: always sending login alerts from any computer.