Jetpack — Publicize stopped showing featured photo

Our site was publishing to facebook fine for months and now publicize will no longer show the feature photo and is instead publishing to facebook another photo from the page. We’ve diasbled Yoast and are still struggling to find and fix the issue. Running the debug through facebook I am able to then post the new link manually and have the correct photo show but not through publicize.

https://www.crossfitwaterbury.com is the site, and it’s our daily posts that have the problem. For example today’s is: https://www.crossfitwaterbury.com/tuesday-10202015-2/

When I run the link through facebook’s debugger, I’m able to then manually post the link and have the proper photo show up – but never through publicize. The error it’s telling me is that more than one OG URL is specified… error message: “Object at URL ‘https://www.crossfitwaterbury.com/tuesday-10202015-3/’ of type ‘article’ is invalid because it specifies multiple ‘og:url’ values: https://www.crossfitwaterbury.com/tuesday-10202015-3/, https://www.crossfitwaterbury.com/tuesday-10202015-3/.”