Insert renders a link instead of content in elementor

Hello,
I am using your plugin (v3.5.3.2) in elementor (v2.9.2).

1) I input the page slug “create-listing”.
2) I select “Use custom template”.
3) I select “User dashboard create listing”, which is a custom template that came with my theme.

Result: A link “Create Listing” to the create listing page.

Problem: I would like the actual “Create Listing” page to render, not create a link.

Any help on what I am missing will be much appreciated. Thank you in advance!